(no subject)

[tree_and_leaf]

You know how Diana Gabaldon thinks fanfic is totally pornographic and totally evil, like writing rpf about you and someone's daughter and then sending them copies of it?

You know how she ALSO says that her character, Jamie (who suffers various nasty things in the course of the first book alone, including rape and having his hand nailed to a table, and also has lots of fairly pornographic sex) was a tribute to Jamie MacCrimmond† (or at least to his kilt)?

Well. It turns out that she sent a copy of Outlander to Frazer Hines. (Via metafandom).

I think my brain just broke.

Let us, instead, turn to an author who is A Good Thing, namely Jim Butcher. Not only has he got a new policy of giving permission for fanfic to be licensed under creative commons, it turns out that he wrote the Codex Alera books because someone bet him he couldn't write a novel based on the Lost Roman Legions and Pokemon. The flick through I gave Codex Alera didn't inspire me to read it, but weirdly, this makes it all better.

There is a possibility I may be leading a home group on God and fiction, and I am desperate to use the Dresden Files for the purpose (the scene with "The Lord of the Rings" and the airport cleaner who is more than he seems); though I suspect I may have to size the group up first...

Eta: damned_colonial points out that Butcher's policy does not make legal sense. On the other hand, the response of sources close to the author suggests that the point still stands re: Butcher being an all round Good Thing.

† I like Jamie. He is sweet and loyal, and while he may be a bit dim, I don't think he deserves any of that....

Comments

[grlnamedlucifer]

... I am utterly horrified by that. Like, whatever, you want to base your character on Jamie, fine (just don't then hypocritically bitch about fanfic), but then to send the book depicting horrible things you've done to said character to his actor? Even if she was breaking the common sense of "leave the actors alone, they probably don't want to read your fanfic," I cannot fathom what response she was hoping for with that one.

[tree_and_leaf]

I know. It's incomprehensible on multiple levels

[fannishnonsense]

I completely do not understand that woman's thought processes. Like, at all.

Also, I seem not to have a Jamie icon. Weird.

[tree_and_leaf]

Every time I think her ideas can't get more internally inconsistent, they do.

And I feel sorry for Frazer Hines, although I suppose he's been an object of fandom for long enough to have seen some pretty weird shit go down...